It Is Written

A Wall of Separation

Three Angels Broadcasting Network

Program transcript

Participants:

Home

Series Code: IIW

Program Code: IIW017154S


00:09 ♪[Theme music]♪
00:18 >>John Bradshaw: This is It Is Written.
00:21 I'm John Bradshaw. Thanks for joining me.
00:23 1620: one of the most significant dates
00:27 in the history of the United State,
00:30 and it wouldn't be a stretch to say,
00:31 in the history of the world.
00:34 ♪[Music]♪
00:41 Martin Luther had nailed the Ninety-Five Theses to the door
00:45 of the Castle Church in Wittenberg 103 years earlier.
00:50 By 1620, Luther had been dead for more than 70 years,
00:55 John Calvin for nearly 60;
00:57 Ulrich Zwingli had died almost 90 years before;
01:01 Theodore Beza, the disciple of Calvin whose likeness
01:04 is on the Reformation Wall in Geneva,
01:07 John Knox who stands to his left,
01:09 the Englishmen William Tyndale, Thomas Cranmer,
01:12 Nicholas Ridley, and Hugh Latimer--
01:14 they'd all been gone for decades.
01:16 In fact, by the time you get to 1620,
01:19 the recognizable names of the Reformation
01:21 had all moved off the scene.
01:24 It could be said that the Reformation ended
01:27 around that time,
01:28 with many scholars saying that it came to an end
01:31 with the Peace of Westphalia in 1648,
01:35 a number of treaties that ended the religious wars in Europe.
01:40 So at about the time the Reformation ended,
01:42 one of the most significant developments in the proclamation
01:45 of God's Word was getting underway.
01:47 And you could see God's fingerprints all over it.
02:02 If you've never seen it before, Plymouth Rock,
02:04 45 minutes south of Boston, in Plymouth, Massachusetts,
02:08 comes as a bit of a surprise.
02:11 The legend is that Plymouth Rock is where the Pilgrims
02:14 got off the Mayflower when they arrived on these shores in 1620.
02:19 The fact is this is only a fragment
02:21 of the original Plymouth Rock.
02:24 The original broke in half in 1774,
02:27 and souvenir hunters chipped away at the rock over the years,
02:30 so there's much less of it today than there once was.
02:34 Now, I know you don't always want the facts
02:35 to get in the way of a good story,
02:37 but another fact is that no one ever claimed the Pilgrims
02:41 landed at Plymouth Rock until 1741,
02:45 121 years after the Mayflower arrived in Plymouth Harbor.
02:52 But all that's incidental, really.
02:54 The rock itself is not what's important.
02:56 Today it's a symbol, a symbol of new beginnings
03:00 and the pioneer spirit.
03:02 It's an icon visited by more than a million people a year.
03:07 So what were the Pilgrims doing, anyway,
03:09 landing at Plymouth Rock, or wherever it was they landed?
03:13 Understand that and you'll understand
03:15 the birth of a great nation,
03:17 and you'll see how the guiding hand of God shepherded
03:20 His people and fostered the growth of the principles
03:24 of the Protestant Reformation.
03:26 So let's back up a few years.
03:30 The Pilgrims on board the Mayflower were Puritans,
03:34 English Protestants who were committed to purifying
03:37 the Church of England of Catholic practices.
03:40 The seeds for the English Reformation were sown by Patrick
03:44 and Columba and Aidan and others like them.
03:46 Centuries later, John Wycliffe was described as
03:50 "the Morning Star of the Reformation."
03:52 And then there was William Tyndale,
03:54 who heroically stood up against King Henry VIII
03:57 and translated the Bible into English at a time
03:59 when such a translation was desperately needed.
04:03 With his dying breath,
04:04 Tyndale prayed that God would open the eyes of Henry VIII,
04:08 which God did only two years later when the king
04:11 gave his permission for four different translations
04:14 of the Bible into the English language.
04:16 It was Tyndale's scholarship that provided the lion's share
04:19 of the King James Version of the Bible.
04:22 ♪[Music]♪
04:32 ♪[Music]♪
04:38 But even though the church in England,
04:39 or the Church of England,
04:41 had separated from Rome, it was in desperate need of reform.
04:45 Now, while it's true that England's King Henry VIII
04:48 was strongly motivated to separate
04:50 from the Roman Catholic Church because it would not annul
04:53 his marriage to Catherine of Aragon in the 1530s,
04:56 England's antipathy towards Rome ran much deeper than that.
05:00 There were significant doctrinal issues that separated the two,
05:04 but the Puritans wanted even more than that.
05:11 Even though the Church of England
05:12 was structurally independent from Rome,
05:15 that wasn't enough for the Puritans.
05:17 They believed that when it came to matters of Christian faith
05:20 and Christian worship,
05:22 that to depart from what the Bible said
05:23 was both unnecessary and unwise.
05:26 They wanted to follow the example of the Lutherans,
05:30 or the Reformed Protestants elsewhere in Europe,
05:33 and return to what they believed
05:34 was a more biblical form of Christianity.
05:38 Yet, the Church of England continued to embrace many
05:41 of the forms of Catholicism.
05:47 The Protestant movement was separated largely
05:49 into two wings:
05:52 the Lutheran-Calvinistic wing, often called Reformed theology,
05:57 primarily after the teachings of Martin Luther and John Calvin,
06:00 and the Arminian wing, which was patterned after the teachings
06:03 of Jacob Arminius and others who focused
06:06 on the role of Christian free will in the salvation process,
06:10 along with practical teaching, such as non-participation in war
06:13 and separation of church and state.
06:15 The Puritans of England clearly took their beliefs
06:19 from the Lutheran- Calvinistic wing.
06:21 And this would be demonstrated by their views
06:23 on religious freedom,
06:25 particularly when they came to the New World.
06:29 The Puritans played a significant role
06:31 in the political history of England
06:32 throughout the 17th century.
06:35 For a time, the Puritans ruled the country under the leadership
06:38 of Lord Protector Oliver Cromwell
06:41 during the 1650s.
06:47 Early in the 1600s, King James I decided
06:50 that he would not tolerate the agitation of the Puritans
06:53 any longer.
06:54 They'd either come into line with the policies and practices
06:56 of the Church of England, or they would leave.
06:59 And many of them left.
07:01 It was difficult for those who lived in England.
07:03 Many of them began describing themselves as Separatists
07:06 because they came to the conclusion
07:08 that the Church of England was never going to change.
07:12 Many of them fled to the Dutch Republic,
07:14 which at the time was more favorable
07:16 to Reformed Protestantism.
07:18 Life was hard for those immigrants.
07:19 Many of them had been farmers,
07:21 and they were not able to farm in their new homeland.
07:24 Instead, they had to learn a trade.
07:27 But they considered these difficulties just part
07:29 of God's way of forming in them a godly character.
07:34 "They knew they were pilgrims,
07:35 and looked not much on those things,
07:37 but lifted up their eyes to heaven,
07:39 their dearest country, and quieted their spirits."
07:45 But many of those Pilgrims chose to leave the Netherlands
07:48 and return to England before leaving again
07:52 onboard a ship called the Mayflower.
07:55 They were headed for the New World.
07:58 Now some Pilgrims didn't make it.
08:00 I'll tell you more in just a moment.
08:02 ♪[Music]♪
08:10 >>John: I'm John Bradshaw from It Is Written,
08:12 inviting you to join me for "500,"
08:16 nine programs produced by It Is Written,
08:18 taking you deep into the Reformation.
08:21 This is the 500th anniversary of the beginning of the Reformation
08:25 when Martin Luther nailed his Ninety-Five Theses to the door
08:28 of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, Germany.
08:30 We'll take you to Wittenberg,
08:32 and to Belgium, to England, to Ireland,
08:35 to Rome, to the Vatican City,
08:37 and introduce you to the people who created the Reformation,
08:40 who pushed the Reformation forward.
08:42 We'll take you to sites all throughout Europe
08:44 where the reformers lived and, in some cases, died.
08:47 We'll bring you back to the United States
08:49 and take you to a little farm in upstate New York
08:52 and show you how God spread the Reformation here.
08:55 Don't miss "500."
08:57 You can own the "500" series on DVD.
09:00 Call us on 888-664-5573
09:04 or visit us online at itiswritten.shop.
09:11 >>John Bradshaw: This is It Is Written.
09:13 There were actually two ships that left England,
09:16 bound for what would become known as
09:18 the United States of America.
09:21 There was the Mayflower and the Speedwell.
09:24 Together they left Southampton on August the 5th, 1620,
09:28 but the Speedwell leaked--
09:31 not great for a ship intending to cross the Atlantic Ocean.
09:35 Both ships stopped in Dartmouth
09:37 so the Speedwell could be repaired.
09:39 After leaving Dartmouth,
09:41 they made it 350 miles beyond Land's End
09:44 before it was discovered that the Speedwell
09:47 was taking on water again.
09:50 So, once more, they returned to Dartmouth.
09:54 The Mayflower decided it would push on without the Speedwell.
09:58 Some of the Speedwell's passengers crammed
10:00 into the Mayflower, and so the Mayflower,
10:02 with 102 passengers and between 25 and 30 crew,
10:06 headed off on what would be a miserable voyage,
10:11 but they made it.
10:12 Slowly but surely,
10:14 life was established here in this new land.
10:17 More and more people would follow in the footsteps,
10:19 or in the wake, of the Pilgrims of England.
10:23 ♪[Music]♪
10:30 They were driven by a desire for liberty of conscience,
10:36 but they really didn't understand what that truly was.
10:44 The idea that God has given the right to control the conscience
10:48 to the church and has given the church the right to define
10:52 and punish heresy is a school of thought
10:55 that came right out of Rome.
11:02 So while these people had rejected
11:04 many of the doctrines of Rome,
11:06 they retained the spirit of Rome: intolerance.
11:11 Any church they set up would ultimately be a church-state.
11:15 They dictated that only church members
11:17 could have a say in government.
11:19 The secular power was in the hands of the church,
11:23 which can only lead in one direction: persecution.
11:31 ♪[Music]♪
11:36 In 1631, when Boston was a brand-new settlement,
11:40 a Puritan minister, not 30 years old, arrived here from England.
11:44 Roger Williams was a Separatist.
11:46 He believed that for a person to be truly faithful to God,
11:49 that person should separate from the Anglican Church.
11:53 He and his wife Mary would have six children,
11:55 all born in the New World:
11:57 Mary, Freeborn, Providence, Mercy,
12:02 Daniel, and Joseph.
12:04 It wasn't long and people knew he was here.
12:07 ♪[Music]♪
12:11 Roger Williams was the first person in this land
12:14 to stand up for something that today we regard as a right.
12:18 He believed that liberty of conscience
12:20 was the inalienable right of all people,
12:24 whatever their religion.
12:26 He went so far as to establish government
12:28 upon the principle of religious freedom.
12:31 He was the first person in modern Christianity to do that.
12:35 Williams believed that the government had no place
12:37 dictating to individuals when it came to religious matters.
12:41 That was an entirely new way of thinking.
12:43 It was revolutionary.
12:46 In the early days of the colonies,
12:48 church attendance was required by law.
12:52 You could be fined or even imprisoned
12:55 for not attending church.
12:57 Williams was scandalized by this,
13:00 and he decided to do something about it.
13:03 >>Lincoln Steed: And it didn't trouble the Puritans whatsoever,
13:06 that while they'd left a bad situation
13:08 to come to the New World, they just set the same model,
13:11 where they would say everyone had to go to church.
13:13 You'd be fined.
13:14 You had to, uh, abide by what the minister said.
13:17 No freelance religion.
13:19 Uh, Roger Williams comes along,
13:22 and he was the conscience and really the, the, uh,
13:26 the guiding light of the true principles of religious liberty
13:30 that we're keeping alive today.
13:32 >>John: It seems strange to be talking about a battle
13:35 over religious freedom in the United States,
13:37 but keep in mind the times and the mindset then.
13:41 The church of Rome had taught very thoroughly
13:43 that there was no religious freedom.
13:44 It claimed to be the voice of God in the world.
13:48 The church spoke;
13:49 church members did what they were expected to do.
13:52 So even though the Church of England had separated
13:55 from the Roman Catholic Church,
13:56 it still retained a lot of Rome's ideas.
14:00 So when the Puritans came to the free world,
14:04 they were still hung up on the concept of the church saying,
14:07 "Jump!" and the faithful saying, "How high?"
14:10 They had not embraced the concept of religious liberty.
14:14 So in spite of the Reformation, further reform was still needed.
14:19 So while the Pilgrims and other Puritan settlers came
14:22 to these shores for the purpose of exercising
14:24 their own liberty of conscience,
14:27 many didn't believe in extending the same right
14:29 to those who held different beliefs.
14:31 Freedom was fine for themselves,
14:34 but not for people who taught and practiced things
14:36 they disagreed with.
14:38 One historian described this attitude with these words:
14:40 "New England divines (pastors and theologians)
14:44 insisted repeatedly that demand for uniformity
14:47 of religious practice in no way violated liberty of conscience.
14:52 They contended that there were two types of liberty:
14:56 natural (or corrupted) liberty
14:57 and the 'liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free.'
15:02 Liberty to practice error came under the former heading
15:05 and was not really liberty at all,
15:08 but license, the 'liberty for men to destroy themselves.'"
15:13 Roger Williams is truly one of the towering figures
15:16 in the American story.
15:17 And he's one of the towering figures in the advance
15:20 of the Word of God.
15:22 Not only did he advocate religious freedom for all,
15:25 he was also one of the earliest and most vocal opponents
15:28 of slavery on these shores.
15:31 He advocated fair treatment for Native American tribes.
15:34 He also learned many of the languages
15:36 of the tribes in the Northeast.
15:38 He'd run into trouble with the Anglican Church
15:40 before he came to America.
15:42 When he got here and he found the same principles
15:44 of intolerance in a place that was supposed to be
15:46 a haven for liberty, it disturbed him.
15:49 He did not agree with the Puritans' attempts
15:51 to set up a theocracy.
15:53 He said, "Forced worship stinks in the nostrils of God."
15:58 Williams believed that Constantine
16:00 was worse for the church than Nero
16:04 because Constantine successfully united the power
16:07 of the civil government with the authority of the church.
16:11 And before long,
16:12 things would get much worse for Roger Williams.
16:17 I'll have more in a moment.
16:18 ♪[Music]♪
16:24 ♪[Music]♪
16:26 >>Announcer: In Matthew 4:4, the Word of God says,
16:29 "It is written, 'Man shall not live by bread alone,
16:32 but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God.'"
16:35 "Every Word" is a one-minute Bible-based daily devotional
16:39 presented by Pastor John Bradshaw
16:41 and designed especially for busy people like you.
16:44 Look for "Every Word" on selected networks,
16:47 or watch it online every day on our website:
16:49 itiswritten.com.
16:51 Receive a daily spiritual boost. Watch "Every Word."
16:55 You'll be glad you did.
16:59 ♪["Every Word" theme music]♪
17:05 >>John Bradshaw: Five hundred years
17:06 after the Protestant Reformation began
17:07 on October the 31st, 1517,
17:10 we might be tempted to wonder what Luther and Knox
17:12 and Zwingli and Calvin and Farel and Beza
17:14 and the Huguenots and the Anabaptists
17:16 and so many others achieved.
17:19 Today it would seem that the protest is over,
17:21 even though the most influential church in the world
17:23 offers indulgences, hears confessions,
17:26 teaches justification by faith and works,
17:28 considers Mary the queen of heaven.
17:31 Where are the Protestants today?
17:32 Protestants are being welcomed back into the church of Rome,
17:35 and many see this as positive.
17:37 It's been said it's more important to be divided by truth
17:40 than it is to be united by error.
17:43 Paul said in 2 Timothy 4, verse 2,
17:45 "Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season;
17:48 reprove, rebuke, exhort with all long suffering and doctrine."
17:52 The Word--anything less will never do.
17:55 I'm John Bradshaw for It Is Written.
17:57 Let's live today by every word.
18:00 [Insects rasping]
18:01 ♪[Music]♪
18:13 >>John Bradshaw: A hundred years after the Reformation ended,
18:16 there was still a lot of reform left to be accomplished.
18:20 As long as there was no liberty of conscience,
18:22 and as long as the state was united with the church,
18:25 the church was a long way short of where it should be,
18:28 from a biblical perspective.
18:30 The man who would bring the needed change was
18:32 a Cambridge-educated Englishman who moved to the colonies
18:35 six weeks after his 27th birthday.
18:39 Williams was forced to leave Massachusetts,
18:42 and he went into exile in 1636.
18:46 In the winter, he journeyed through the forests,
18:49 not knowing where he was going.
18:51 Along the way he made friends with many of the natives
18:53 and later said that he would rather live
18:55 with "Christian savages" than "savage Christians."
18:59 His journeys led him here,
19:01 to a place that he would name "Providence,"
19:04 convinced that the providence of God had guided him.
19:08 ♪[Music]♪
19:16 It was Roger Williams, not Thomas Jefferson,
19:19 who first coined the phrase "wall of separation,"
19:22 so far as church and state are concerned.
19:25 In 1644, Williams described the need to build
19:27 a "wall of separation between the garden of the church
19:32 and the wilderness of the world."
19:34 Leonard Levy, a U.S. constitutional scholar,
19:37 commented on these words of Roger Williams
19:39 with the following statement:
19:41 "Thus, the wall of separation had the allegiance
19:44 of a most profound Christian impulse
19:47 as well as a secular one.
19:49 To Christian fundamentalists of the Framers' time
19:52 the wall of separation derived from the biblical injunction
19:55 that Christ's kingdom is not of this world."
19:59 The fundamental principle of Roger Williams' colony
20:02 was that every man should have liberty to worship God
20:05 according to the light of his own conscience.
20:08 Rhode Island's founding principles,
20:11 civil and religious liberty,
20:13 became the cornerstones of the American republic.
20:16 This was extremely significant.
20:19 And so today, the Declaration of Independence states:
20:23 "We hold these truths to be self-evident,
20:26 that all men are created equal;
20:29 that they are endowed by their Creator
20:30 with certain unalienable rights;
20:33 that among these are life, liberty,
20:36 and the pursuit of happiness."
20:39 And the Constitution guarantees freedom of conscience
20:42 in religious matters.
20:43 "No religious test shall ever be required as a qualification
20:48 to any office of public trust under the United States."
20:52 "Congress shall make no law respecting
20:54 an establishment of religion,
20:56 or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."
21:00 It was this environment that allowed the preaching
21:02 and the teaching of the Bible to flourish.
21:05 Of course, there have been those who have abused
21:08 their religious freedom,
21:09 but just think of the alternative:
21:11 a world in which you're not free to believe what you believe.
21:15 That's the world Martin Luther faced when he nailed
21:17 the Ninety-Five Theses to that famous door back in 1517.
21:23 Word began to spread back in Europe
21:24 about a place where a person could worship God
21:26 according to the dictates of his or her own conscience.
21:30 As one historian wrote, "Massachusetts,
21:33 by special law, offered free welcome and aid,
21:36 at the public cost, to Christians of any nationality
21:39 who might fly beyond the Atlantic
21:41 'to escape from wars or famine,
21:43 or the oppression of their persecutors.'
21:45 [And so] the fugitive and the downtrodden were,
21:48 by statute, made the guests of the commonwealth."
21:52 The colonies grew, and the world saw the prosperity
21:56 and the increasing strength of a church without a pope
22:00 and a state without a king.
22:03 In this patch of earth, Roger Williams raised up
22:05 a memorial to religious freedom.
22:08 The establishment of the Rhode Island colony was
22:10 a landmark event in the history of the Protestant Reformation,
22:15 a new haven in a new land where people would finally be free,
22:20 to follow the dictates of their own conscience
22:22 when it came to matters of faith.
22:24 Even the Puritans of Roger Williams' day
22:26 couldn't accept his thinking.
22:28 You see, it was the prevailing belief 400 or so years ago
22:31 that the civil government had every right
22:34 to dictate to people's conscience.
22:36 That did not sit well with Roger Williams,
22:38 and it led him into deep conflict.
22:41 But the conflict that he experienced brought,
22:43 to everyone that followed, freedom.
22:47 ♪[Music]♪
22:52 Now, of course that meant that if you wanted to opt out,
22:55 to practice no religion, to disagree with the church,
22:58 then it was your right to do so.
23:01 And it's this spirit of religious liberty
23:03 that's described in the New Testament,
23:05 just a few verses from the end of the Bible,
23:08 where the bride of Christ blends her appeal
23:11 with that of the Holy Spirit in urging humanity
23:14 to accept God's gift of salvation.
23:17 "And the Spirit and the bride say, 'Come!'
23:20 And let him who hears say, 'Come!'
23:24 And let him who thirsts come.
23:27 [And] whoever desires, let him take the water of life freely."
23:33 Freedom of conscience would take hold in America in a way
23:36 not seen in any other civil experiment in human history.
23:41 The inalienable right to worship and follow conscience,
23:44 as a person chooses, would become
23:47 one of the main cornerstones of the American experience
23:50 and of the final stages of the Protestant Reformation.
23:54 ♪[Music]♪
24:00 Roger Williams demonstrated how important it is
24:03 for believers to press forward.
24:06 While the Reformation accomplished an enormous amount,
24:08 in terms of opening up the Bible and bringing the light
24:11 of God's Word to the human mind,
24:14 there was still a lot left to accomplish,
24:16 much more to learn,
24:18 more for the church and more for believers
24:20 as they grew towards God's ideal.
24:24 John Robinson was a pastor of Pilgrims in Holland,
24:28 and he said this to many who were preparing to leave
24:30 for the New World:
24:32 "Brethren, we are now erelong to part asunder,
24:36 and the Lord knoweth whether I shall live ever
24:39 to see your faces more.
24:42 But whether the Lord hath appointed it or not,
24:44 I charge you before God and His blessed angels
24:47 to follow me no farther than I have followed Christ.
24:53 If God should reveal anything to you
24:55 by any other instrument of His,
24:57 be as ready to receive it as ever you were to receive
25:01 any truth of my ministry;
25:04 for I am very confident the Lord hath more truth and light
25:09 yet to break forth out of His holy word."
25:14 I'm confident the Lord has more.
25:16 God has more for you in His Word.
25:20 That was true in the time of the Pilgrims,
25:23 and that commitment to the Bible,
25:24 to the progress of God's light would lead others to advance
25:28 the cause of the Reformation and guide multitudes
25:32 into a deeper understanding of God and His Word.
25:36 ♪[Music]♪
25:43 >>John: How can you enjoy a successful Christian experience?
25:47 How can you know victory instead of defeat?
25:50 How can you live with honor and integrity before God?
25:55 Well, you can, and our free offer today tells you how.
25:57 To receive "The War Is Over,"
25:59 call us on 800-253-3000
26:02 or visit us online at itiswritten.com,
26:06 or you can write to the address on your screen.
26:08 I'd like you to receive our free offer,
26:10 "The War Is Over."
26:13 Thank you for remembering that It Is Written exists
26:16 due to the gracious support of people like you.
26:19 It's your kindness that makes it possible for It Is Written
26:22 to share Jesus and the great truths of the Bible
26:25 with the world.
26:26 You can send your tax-deductible gift
26:28 to the address on your screen,
26:30 or you can support It Is Written
26:31 through our website: itiswritten.com.
26:35 Thanks for your generous support.
26:36 Our number is 800-253-3000
26:39 and our web address is itiswritten.com.
26:44 >>John Bradshaw: Let's pray together now.
26:45 Our Father in heaven,
26:47 we're thankful today that we have Your Word
26:49 and that we have freedom to worship You.
26:52 And to believe what we wish to believe,
26:53 according to the dictates of our conscience.
26:55 We thank You for the wall of separation
26:58 that You have erected to protect our freedom,
27:02 to prevent others from dictating to us what we should believe.
27:06 So, Lord, with that religious freedom, I pray for wisdom,
27:10 for grace, that we might exercise that freedom
27:13 in a way that grows us into Your image,
27:17 that leads us in the direction of Your Holy Spirit.
27:23 Now, Father, there's somebody thinking
27:25 that they must give You their heart.
27:26 I pray, draw that man, that woman,
27:28 that young person right now,
27:30 that decisions will be made even now,
27:32 that we will value this freedom we have,
27:34 given to us at great cost.
27:37 And use it in a way that will lead us into Your kingdom.
27:40 We look for that day, that day of Jesus' return.
27:42 May it be soon, we pray.
27:44 Take our hearts and make them Yours.
27:46 We ask You in Jesus' name.
27:50 Amen.
27:52 Thanks for joining me.
27:53 I'm looking forward to seeing you again next time.
27:55 Until then, remember:
27:56 "It is written, 'Man shall not live by bread alone,
28:01 but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God.'"
28:06 ♪[Theme music]♪
28:16 ♪[Theme music]♪


Home

Revised 2020-05-20